Religion and Violence: A Bibliography

Compiled by Charles K. Bellinger

[This is an expanded version of a bibliography published in The Hedgehog Review 6/1 (2004): 111-119.]

 

The literature on religion and violence was already substantial before the Sept. 11 attacks, and it has swelled at an increased pace since then. I have not seen abundant evidence, however, that the serious reflections on violence expressed in these books has made a noticeable impact on the shape of higher education, on news media reporting, or on the thinking of government officials around the world. This is unfortunate.

Popular opinion doesn't reflect on the complexity of violence. We assume that violence (that is, the violence done by others) is evil, but we don't understand it and seem to have little interest in understanding it. The authors listed below are trying to change that situation in both respects. They invite us to develop an interest in reflecting on violence and offer substantive understandings of it from their own perspectives. I foresee a time in the future when their efforts will bear fruit as a "critical mass" of interest develops and overcomes the apathy of our current situation. At that point, the ideas contained in these books will begin to have a significant impact on higher education, the media, and governmental and military decision-making.

I will append to each subsection below a short list of Library of Congress Subject Headings that will enable the reader to explore the topic further. The numbers in parentheses indicate the number of books that have been assigned that subject heading that fit the following parameters as of December, 2005: English language, published from 1980 to 2005, held by at least 50 libraries (according to WorldCat).

 

Social Science Perspectives

The books listed here are primarily analyses of violence written by psychologists, anthropologists, and sociologists. Becker's work develops a theory of "death denial" as the root of violence. Alford's book is an updated version of Becker. Bauman argues that Naziism was the logical outcome of modern technological advances and concern for efficiency. The set of four volumes edited by Ellens is a major contribution to this topic, presenting essays by an impressive gathering of scholars in various fields. Volume 3 of Stout's collection of essays is similar. Jung is a widely read shaper of contemporary psychological thought.

Library of Congress Subject Headings:
Genocide -- Psychological aspects. (24)
Good and evil -- Psychological aspects. (27)
Religion and Psychology. (236)
Shame. (108)
Violence -- Psychological aspects. (154)
War -- Psychological aspects. (99)
 

 

Humanities and Religious Studies Perspectives

The books included in this section are written from the perspectives of religious studies, or philosophy, history, literature, or journalism that includes attention to religious traditions. Appleby, Juergensmeyer, and Kimball have offered widely read commentaries on the various ways in which religion and violence are related to each other in the contemporary world. The Chase and Jacobs volume contains papers given at a major conference on Christianity and violence, including a lively debate between Stanley Hauerwas and John Milbank on the ethics of violence. The Jewett and Lawrence book criticizes the tendency of Americans to simplistically identify themselves with good and their enemies with evil. The Marty and Appleby book is part of an important five volume series analyzing fundamentalism. There is also a growing strand of books on cults, new religious movements, etc., in relation to violence.

Library of Congress Subject Headings:
Social conflict -- Religious aspects. (12)

Violence -- Religious aspects. (153)
War -- Religious aspects. (180)

 

Rene Girard, His Followers and Critics

If there is one voice that stands out in the realm of reflections on religion and violence, it is certainly that of René Girard. His religiously framed and interdisciplinary theory of human psychology and cultural formation through violence has already spawned a large secondary literature of response and critical commentary. Many of these works take Girard's ideas and restate, popularize, or apply them to specific topics, and are written from the perspective of an admiring follower. My contribution, The Genealogy of Violence, brings Girard's ideas into conversation with the insights into human behavior that are present in Kierkegaard's thought.

In my opinion, Girard ought to be nominated for the Nobel Prize for Literature (or Peace), but it is doubtful that he is even on the radar screen of the nominating committee. If that Prize can be given to Sartre and Churchill, it could certainly be given to an author whose ideas are likely to make a significant contribution to any substantive improvement in human self-understanding that may occur in the 21st century.

A significant database of information on primary and secondary works relating to Girard is located on the web site of the Colloquium on Violence and Religion.
http://theol.uibk.ac.at/cover/

Library of Congress Subject Headings:
Girard, René, 1923-. (21)
Sacrifice. (110)
Scapegoat. (16)
Violence -- Religious aspects -- Christianity. (66)

 

Commentaries on Islam, Violence, and Terrorism

This is a sampling of the many works that were published before the Sept. 11 attacks, and some since then, that consider the relationship between Islam and violence. Many of these works have the conscious intention of providing a counterbalance to the distorted views of Islam that are unfortunately widespread in the West. Huntington's work describing the "bloody borders of Islam" has provoked much discussion and critique in academic circles (including the book by Jonathan Sacks listed in the "Peacemaking and Conflict Resolution" section below). James Turner Johnson, Bruce B. Lawrence, and Bernard Lewis are widely recognized as "deans" of this field of study.

Library of Congress Subject Headings:
Islamic Fundamentalism. (198)

Jihad. (87)
Terrorism--Psychological aspects. (50)
Terrorism--Religious aspects. (161)
War -- Religious aspects -- Islam. (30)

 

Responses to 9/11

If you are imagining that there has been a flood of books written about the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, you are right. This is a very selective listing of some of them. The current Archbishop of Canterbury, Rowan Williams, who happened to have been in Manhattan on the day of the attacks, has offered thoughtful reflections on how the West ought to work through its emotional and political/ethical response to terrorism. Cooper draws on the philosophy of Eric Voegelin. Esposito, Lewis, Stern, and Lincoln are experts on Islam with important insights to offer from their years of study.

Library of Congress Subject Headings:
September 11 Terrorist Attacks, 2001. (588)

Sermons

 

Peacemaking and Conflict Resolution

Out of the immense literature on peacemaking in general, I have selected some of the works that specifically focus on religious aspects of the problem. Lederach and Stassen are leaders in the area of conflict resolution strategizing. The Easwaran book tells the fascinating story of Badshah Khan, a Muslim associate of Gandhi. The Chappell, Goleman, and Nhât Hanh books present Buddhist perspectives on peace. Gopin is a Jewish scholar deeply involved in issues of inter-religious dialogue between Jews, Christians, and Muslims in the Middle East. Volf, Wink, and Yoder are significant contributors to theological discussions of peacemaking in Christian circles. The activism and writings of Gandhi and Martin Luther King, Jr. have influenced many of the works listed in this section.

Library of Congress Subject Headings:
Conflict management -- Religious aspects. (48)

Nonviolence -- Biblical teaching. (11)
Peace -- Moral and ethical aspects. (28)
Peace -- Religious aspects. (314)